A note on the D. mauritiana Pw+ insert lines and their derivatives Yun Tao April 20, 2004 The Pw+ insert lines of D. mauritiana constructed by True, Mercer and Laurie (1996, Genetics 142: 507-523) has been used in studying hybrid incompatibilities between D. mauritiana and D. simulans through an introgression approach (True, Weir and Laurie 1996, Genetics 142: 819-837; Tao, Hartl and Laurie 2001 PNAS 98: 13183-13188;Tao, Chen, Hartl and Laurie 2003, Genetics 164: 1383-1397; Tao, Zeng, Li, Hartl and Laurie 2003, Genetics 164: 1399-1418; Tao and Hartl 2003 Evolution 57: 2580-2598). It can be said that more follow-up studies will be published in the next few years (Y. Tao, J. P. Masly, L. Araripe, A. Orr, A. G. Clark, D. L. Hartl, unpublished work). In the next decade, the D. mauritiana Pw+ lines and their introgressive derivatives are likely to become valuable resources in the field of genetics of speciation. The D. mauritiana Pw+ stocks are now kept by J. P. Masly (graduate student in Allen Orr's lab of the University of Rochester) and Y. Tao (research associate with Dan Hartl of Harvard University). JPM and YT back up each other for these stocks, most of which have survived through the years. A list of the stocks still alive can be found in Tao (personal communication to FlyBase, 2002.12.8). Recently, Dr. Gillian Millburn, FlyBase curator, has risen a question about the nomenclature used for the D. mauritiana Pw+ stocks and their derivatives: Dear Dr. Tao, I am curating your paper for FlyBase: Tao et al., 2003, Genetics 164(4): 1383--1397 and I have a question about a few of the D.mauritiana insertion lines that were used to mark the introgressed segments \- whch are shown in Figure 4. 1. 21 71F72A in your personal communication to FlyBase: FBrf0155355 == Tao, 2002.12.8, personal communication to FlyBase there it lists information for the '71F72A' cytological position: line name insert cyt pos 4Z2, 4Z3 71F72A when I curated this before, I took this to mean that there are 2 separate lines that have an insert at 71F-72A and made 2 separate insertion records \- one called 'P{lacW}mau-4Z2' for the 4Z2 strain and one called 'P{lacW}mau-4Z3' for the 4Z3 strain. Was I correct in this assumption \- are there 2 different inserts at 71F-72A in the 2 different lines ? If so, which line does '21 71F72A' from your Genetics paper correspond to ? I have contacted John True for this question: John, In the past several years, I have the honor of keeping your D. mau P lines as great resources for the Drosophila research community. Various questions have been risen on these lines, I have been able to answer most of them. However, occasionally there are nasty ones. Here is one example (see the text of Gillian's question): In Gillian's question 1, line 71F72A (as in your Table A1 of Genetics 1996 paper) actually has two lines, 4Z2 and 4Z3, as physically labeled and kept for stocks. I re-labeled 71F72A as line \#21 in my Genetics 2003 paper. I need to go back my original lab notes to figure out which line 4Z2 or 4Z3 I actually used. Are 4Z2 and 4Z3 actually two independent lines? or duplicates of the same line? The same questions apply to (F2, F3c 91A), (3A1 3A2 92E), (3Q3, 3Q3a 56DE) \- If they are duplicates, then it is easy to answer the questions. If they are separate inserts, then it may be very difficult to figure out which line you actually used in the Genetics 1996 paper \- even if Cathy still keeps your original notes. Hope I have made the question clear. If not, let's talk through phone next week. I will be out of town this weekend and next Monday, so I may call you next Tuesday if I am still not sure. Best, Yun John's answer is clear (email to YT on April 16, 2004): Hi Yun, lines with the same prefix (e.g. 4Z and F) are from the same G0 and are likely to be the same insert (this is pretty much assumed if they map to the same cytological location, but it was not checked molecularly). Therefore, all of the groups you mentioned are assumed (and extremely likely to be \- although this is not confirmed at the molecular level) the same insert. John In our introgression studies (Tao, Hartl and Laurie 2001 PNAS 98: 13183-13188;Tao, Chen, Hartl and Laurie 2003, Genetics 164: 1383-1397; Tao, Zeng, Li, Hartl and Laurie 2003, Genetics 164: 1399-1418; Tao and Hartl 2003 Evolution 57: 2580-2598), three of the four lines in question have been used. I went back to my old notes and found the following connections (see Tao and Hartl 2003 Evolution 57: 2580-2598 for a full list of all the introgression lines mentioned): 1. All lines of Pw+ \#21 were derived from 4Z3 71F72A; 2. Lines of 44.3, 44.5 and 44B were derived from 3A1 92E, while 44A was from 3A2 92E; 3. Lines of 41A, 41.1, 41.2, 41.3 and 41.4 were derived from F2 91A, while 41.5 and 41.6 were derived from F2c 91A. Whether these pairs of Pw+ are the same is inconsequential for all the work published so far. The insertion sites of these lines can be sequenced through inverse PCR \- which can be easily done if necessary.