Subject: Re: dANKTM1 to dTRPA1 Dear all, Thanks for quick turnaround on this. Few points: We do not prefix symbols in FlyBase with d for Drosophila (see note at http://fbserver.gen.cam.ac. uk:7081 /docs/nomenclature/lk/nomenclature.html#1.2. for explanation). The use of all caps to denote genes is discouraged, as this causes a lack of distinction between gene and gene product. See http://fbserver.gen.cam.ac. uk:7081 /docs/nomenclature/lk/nomenclature.html#11.1. '11.1. Proteins.' for explanation of this. In terms of initial letter, this new name seems to be based on homology, so the initial letter will be upper case See http://fbserver.gen.cam.ac. uk:7081 /docs/nomenclature/lk/nomenclature.html '1.1.1. Case of initial letter.' I presume you are already aware of the pre-existing gene trp:transient receptor potential (FBgn0003861) \- there will be a danger of your gene being confused with this. trp is a very well established gene symbol and there is no possibility of changing it. Having said all that, the new symbol:name will be TrpA1:Transient receptor potential A1 It will be a while (months, unfortunately) before the next update of genes information on the FlyBase public servers, when this name change will become evident, but I'll start the update process today. Best regards, Rachel. Subject: Re: dANKTM1 to dTRPA1 Hi Rachel \- We are all in agreement that the name should be changed to dTRPA1. Please see attached notes from Tim and from Veena. \- thanks \- Paul Begin forwarded message: > Hi Paul, > > Congratulations on the paper! I think you should change the name of > Drosophila ANKTM1 should be Changed to TRPA1 to reflect its orthology > to mammalian TRPA1 genes. There will be much less confusion in the > field in the future if this name change is made. > > Tim Jegla, Ph.D. > Neurobiology Group Leader > Genomics Institute of the Novartis Research Foundation > 10675 John Jay Hopkins Dr. > San Diego, CA 92121 > Begin forwarded message: > > Hello Paul, > I agree that the name of dANKTM1 should be changed to dTRPA1 in keeping > with the nomenclature, > Thanks, > Veena Viswanath >> Subject: Re: dANKTM1 >> Date: Wed, 23 Feb 2005 10:05:29 \-0500 >> >> Hi Rachel \- No problem. Ardem patapoutian (the corresponding author >> of >> the viswanath paper) is a co-author on our paper. I have e-mailed >> him. >> \- paul >> >> On Feb 23, 2005, at 9:40 AM, Rachel Drysdale (Genetics) wrote: >> >>> Dear Paul, >>> >>> FBgn0035934 was named Anktm1 on account of >>> FBrf0160224 == Viswanath, 2003.5.19, GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ: AY302598 >>> and >>> FBrf0159694 == Viswanath et al., 2003, Nature 423(6942): 822--823 >>> >>> This naming was entirely legitimate, and we do not change gene >>> symbols >>> without good reason (and we generally do not regard name changes in >>> other >>> organisms as good reason). >>> >>> When someone wants a gene symbol change we require the agreement of >>> those who originally named it and those working on the gene (in this >>> case that would minimally be Viswanath and Jegla) not only on what >>> the >>> gene symbol should be, but also that you will all use the new symbol >>> in >>> future publications. So if you want to pursue this please could you >>> email Viswanath and Jegla, and then get back to me, with a >>> coordinated >>> request. We document such name changes in this way so that we do not >>> later reverse the name change, when working from the usual precedence >>> criteria. >>> >>> This might not be quite the reply you were hoping for, but we have >>> had >>> to adopt this ruthlessly pragmatic way of dealing with nomenclature, >>> otherwise (we have learned by experience) mediating nomenclature >>> discussions would take up a huge proportion of our time for no real >>> gain of data in FlyBase. >>> >>> With best regards, >>> >>> Rachel >>> for FlyBase. >>> >>>> Subject: dANKTM1 >>>> Date: Tue, 22 Feb 2005 16:29:04 \-0500 >>>> >>>> I wanted to request that the name of the gene dANKTM1 >>>> (http://flybase.net/.bin/fbidq.html?FBgn0035934) be changed to >>>> dTRPA1 >>>> to reflect recent standardization of nomenclature in the TRP field. >>>> >>>> In vertebrates, ANKTM1 is now commonly referred to as TRPA1 \--- for >>>> example, the recent Nature article: ' TRPA1 is a candidate for the >>>> mechanosensitive transduction channel of vertebrate hair cells.' >>>> D.P. >>>> Corey et al. (2004) Nature 432:723-730 . >> >>>> We recently published loss-of-function analysis of the fly TRPA1 >>>> ortholog in G&D \--- 'The Drosophila ortholog of vertebrate TRPA1 >>>> regulates thermotaxis.' M. Rosenzweig, K.M. Brennan, T.D. Tayler, >>>> P.O. >>>> Phelps, A. Patapoutian, and P.A. Garrity (2005). Genes & Development >>>> 19:419-424 . >>>> >>>> \- thank you \- >>>> Paul Garrity >>>> >>>> Paul Garrity >>>> MIT Dept. of Biology >>>> 31 Ames Street >>>> Building 68 Room 230B