FB2026_03 , released September 17, 2026
Reference Report
Open Close
Reference
Citation
Kliman, R.M., Rogers, B.T., Noor, M.A.F. (2001). Differences in (G+C) content between species: a commentary on Forsdyke's 'chromosomal viewpoint' of speciation.  J. Theor. Biol. 209(2): 131--140.
FlyBase ID
FBrf0136996
Publication Type
Research paper
Abstract
Forsdyke (1999) has recently argued that differences in (G+C)%, or G+C content, may trigger new species formation. He further argues that the genic model has shortcomings that can be overcome by his "chromosomal" (hereafter, "G+C") model. We disagree on several counts. First, we do not accept that the genic model has the shortcomings suggested by Forsdyke. There is an abundance of empirical support for the contribution of individual genes, as well as of mapped chromosomal regions, to post-zygotic reproductive isolation (and Haldane's rule). Further, we argue that the G+C model suffers from the same theoretical difficulties as other speciation models based on underdominance. We also question the evidence Forsdyke uses to support his model. Finally, we describe analyses of G+C content in a well-studied model system of speciation (the Drosophila melanogaster species complex), the results of which are incompatible with the G+C model. Thus, while Forsdyke's G+C model cannot be explicitly ruled out, it is not directly supported by empirical data. In contrast, the genic model is well supported by empirical data, holds up on theoretical grounds, and does not require any assistance from the G+C model.
PubMed ID
PubMed Central ID
Associated Information
Comments
Associated Files
Other Information
Secondary IDs
    Language of Publication
    English
    Additional Languages of Abstract
    Parent Publication
    Publication Type
    Journal
    Abbreviation
    J. Theor. Biol.
    Title
    Journal of Theoretical Biology
    Publication Year
    1961-
    ISBN/ISSN
    0022-5193
    Data From Reference